Monday, November 18, 2013

Quality Software Design

As noted previously, I have been writing scripts to automate parts of ACKS.  One of those scripts is a treasure generator, for which I designed a configuration file language (really it's a random table description language, but the treasure generator is the main thing I use it for).  I've gradually added in support for rolling dice of dice ( (1d6)d6 and such) and other esoteric features to support hex-stocking, but that's not something I use all that much (well, not recently).

Today, however, while deciding to condition scroll contents on scroll language, however (so that dwarven spell scrolls are always divine, or turtleman spell scrolls have a chance at unique / Player's Companion turtleman spells, or so forth, as part of my grand designs to customize my treasure tables), I ran into a failure in my own foresight in design.  While loading giant lists of spells-by-race-and-level into my main treasure table config, I realized that said file was starting to get a bit lengthy...  up towards a thousand lines.  Not a technical hurdle for my Text Editor of Choice, but somewhat inconvenient to dig through.  And here I had failed to add a #include, import, or other "let me load this other file" feature into my description language!

The danger in actually using a thing you designed is that you might find bugs in it.  This hazard is even more probable if you let other people use a thing you designed.

(And yes, players, I know I should be working on a dungeon instead.  But you haven't told me which dungeon to build first!  I did figure out where the elven treasure map (er, letter) points, though, so that's a thing prepped)

Sunday, November 17, 2013

Scaled Continent Session 1

Report:
  • Sewers partially explored.  Found and fought a gang of snakemen, took their leader prisoner, interrogated.  Knocked the snake door, snakeman volunteered to check hall for traps by trying to escape, was very successful.  Found cursed fake snakeman artifact, then found secret passage to real one.  Decided to undertake expedition to sell fake one to snakemen.  Encountered ruffians in sewers on way out, did not engage.
  • Pursued the bounty on pirates.  Aerial reconnaisance was conducted via amazon riding giant eagle, pirate camp in hidden cove located.  Scouted plantation of former captain rumored to be mysteriously immune to pirate attacks, no evidence of wrongdoing found.  En route to pirate base, encountered hunting party, captured one and slew rest.  Base found in low alert state waiting for hunting party to return with dinner, pirates dispatched easily, captain (8th-level assassin) taken prisoner via bolas while trying to flee.  Much treasure was had, including two ridiculously huge gems, and a small troop transport captured as ship for further expeditions.
  • Technical difficulties - neither google talk nor roll20's voice/vid was cooperative, ended up falling back to skype voice conference + roll20 map / roller.  Voice quality less than fantastic, one player dropped early due to skype bugging out.  Not ideal, but not sure how to fix.
  • Somewhat slow; many and rusty or new players may have contributed.  Carrier-sense multiple access of voice medium also hard without facial and body cues.  I am sorry we ran overtime, Mark and Alex :\
  • No casualties of either PCs or henchmen.  They didn't even have any "oh god we're all going to die" moments :(.  They managed resources well and made quick, single-target expeditions into reasonably safe areas, so partly smart play on their part (and partly that most of their opponents were 1HD mooks suitable for great cleaving).  I will have to do better next time.

Monday, November 11, 2013

On the Road

Only brought work laptop.  Failed to consider that my Scaled Continent notes and scripts are only on my home laptop, not stored in that magical fairyland known to many as The Cloud :\

Progress: slowed.

Still might be able to prep a session for Sunday if some folks party up and tell me where they want to go.

Saturday, November 9, 2013

ACKS Post-Mortem III: That We Might Improve

Matt mentioned "the problem areas we had before" in a chat with me, and I wasn't sure which ones specifically he was talking about.  In turn, and in preparation for Scales, it might be worth enumerating and analyzing alllll the things.  No names will be named, except where things were my fault (spoiler: it's all my fault on some level).

And if there's something I missed, players of last campaign, feel free to chime in.  But here are the things that I perceive made you unhappy.
  • Level inequality.  We had folks bringing 3rd-level characters into a game with 7th-level characters.  In principle, this should work because of exponential XP progression; lower level characters should catch up with higher levels ones within the time it takes the higher-level ones to gain a whole level, assuming equal XP shares for everyone.  In practice, this assumption was disrupted by lack of treasure and separate domains, and became a perpetual source of discontent.
    • Solutions: bring new players in with more XP, or allow existing players to burn reserve XP they probably won't need to boost starting player XP, or allow expenditures from the party treasury to generate reserve XP for a new player which is immediately spent.
  • Lack of treasure.  We were focused on clearing hexes, rather than exploring, finding the high-value lairs, and stealing the fat loots.  Caused by lack of understanding of how to play the mid-level game (and my consequent mishandling of treasure maps) and exacerbated by early domains.
    • Solutions: give many treasure maps, provide clear encouragement to players in the mid-levels to focus on stealing treasure from dragons rather than fighting giant catfish.  
  • Early domains.  We had a 5th-level character basically running a town at one point because they had demolished the existing power structure but none of the other players wanted a domain.  This was the beginning of separate domains, below.  Early domains also led to hex-clearing efforts by weak characters, who ran into a lot of trouble with things that a domain-level character would have dealt with easily.  
    • Solutions: Avoid early domains to force PCs to either trade or raid to reach domain levels, at which time they will have the requisite personal power to clear hexes with relative ease, avoiding boredom and frustration.  Threaten low-level PC rulers with 9th-level bandit leaders and other would-be usurpers on a regular basis.  Strong centralized rulers also good for keeping upstart PCs in their places until strong enough to challenge directly.
  • Separate domains.  Not directly causal of negative symptoms, but a contributing factor (and more of a contributing factor than early domains, I would argue).  Led to loss of cohesion, below.
    • Solutions: make the wilderness threatening enough to domains that PCs must unite or lose their holdings in the early domain levels.  Just like all other levels, really.  I was getting there with the Witches of Bleak, but took too long / damage already done.  Provide for division of domain income among the entire party, reducing incentives to personal domains at early levels (particularly to smooth differences in income between thieves' guilds and fighter domains; develop a cooperative domain ecology).  Standard of living costs may also be intended to restrict available individual cash to the point where unification is the only way to finance a new domain.
  • Loss of cohesion.  The lack of treasure forced people to pursue domain activities in order to gain XP and level.  Because we had separate domains, this led to conflict of interest, 'exploitation' of lower-level players to do dirty / bloody / boring / non-profitable hex-clearing work they weren't really equipped for, and subsequent disenfranchisement.  Seeds of conflict of interest were also present due to conflicting visions / reasons for playing, but probably resolvable if not aggravated by economics.  Multithreading to handle six unrelated schemes at once and stock many hexes contributed to DM overload, quality of game deteriorated, game over man.
    • Solutions:  Avoid separate domains, attempt to maintain common set of party goals.  Communicate!  Less good solutions (patches) include DM intervention in player planning and socialization ("You really ought to hold out for more money to go after those ankhegs..."), and unifying existential threats.
So.  How to avoid these this time?  Fixing lack of treasure and avoiding early domains are clear goals of the operative structure of this game.  Level inequality is a very real possibility with infrequent players, but if most expeditions are acquiring significant treasures, they should end up perpetually one level behind or so rather than four.  This is a mainly numerical problem, hence amenable to any number of mechanical / numerical solutions.  I'm most concerned about loss of cohesion with a playerbase this large; with this many people it would be very easy to let folks run hither and yon for a hundred reasons.  I suspect the best means of maintaining cohesion is player awareness that it is at risk; please communicate your goals with other players and be willing to help others toward their goals with the expectation that they will later help you towards yours (and then hold them to it, rather than clearing hexes for them indefinitely!).

Friday, November 8, 2013

Scaled Continent: Obsidian Portal Up


A bloodstained ring of black volcanic glass stands in this otherwise-pristine jungle clearing.  It is overgrown with vines, and carved in the shape of a snake eating its own tail.  The trees themselves seem to shy away from it.

Let the complaining about their new interface begin.  I have done my best to de-terrible it.  Also, if I don't have your Obsidian Portal username or an email address, I may need it to send you an invite.

Also: upon examination of the vast tracts of land and vast numbers of hostile sentients residing on the continent, I am considering raising starting resources to 20000 XP and 16000 GP.  Input on this matter is requested.

And now to go put stuff on the wiki.

Scaled Continent: Intended Structure of Play

Here's how I see things working out:

The playerbase as a whole agrees on a Base of Operations.  This base is initially Salvation on Voltager.  The relocation of the base is a fairly major to-do, involving the transport of all adventurers, almost-all henchmen, and most portable resources, and requires unanimous consent.  For players of last campaign, think the move from Deal to Opportunity.  It may be possible further into the game to construct forward operating bases in the jungle, but for now only friendly settlements may be used as bases.  I expect that a coastal continental settlement will be chosen as a base fairly early in the game, but I leave the scouting and decision-making to y'all.

Each session, one or more expeditions from the base of operations are undertaken by the players present for the session. Under ideal circumstances, all PCs return to the base of operations at the end of the session.  PCs stuck in the dungeon or wilderness at the end of a session may suffer calamitous fates.  I would like to keep track of time records, and permit the characters of players not present to experience elapsed time, which may be used for hijinks, recruiting, magic research, congregation-building, recovery from mortal wounds or RL&L side effects, awaiting commissioned goods, or other ends.  As much as I harped on our Standard of Living Costs piledriver previously, I don't really see a good way to employ it here without some people getting screwed over, so those will probably not apply (if SoL costs come out of individual pockets, infrequent players get shafted.  If they come out of a common party treasury, then the group will experience large gold losses because it will be paying out 10 people's worth of SoL costs but only earning money with 5 adventurers at a time).  I'm also loathe to intermingle time between sessions and parties (which would fix "5 supporting 10"), because that creates huge headaches and inconsistencies for everyone involved.  Better to have strictly linear time and accept standard of living as a casualty.  I suppose henchman monthly pay will only be owed for sessions in which their players participate, or over time periods where they were undertaking non-adventuring work (hijinks, crafting, &c).  This actually creates a possible compromise position on SoL costs too - one could charge SoL costs for when a PC is doing something, including non-adventuring things.  But that disincentivizes non-adventuring work, which runs counter to the interesting parts of ACKS.  So I think I'm just going to leave SoL costs out, if that's all right with the lot of you.

I expect this whole time structure will react either wonderfully or catactrophically to the shift to domain play, if and when it occurs.  But that can be worried about later.

Given current player base size, I expect two sessions a week may be necessary to maintain interest.  Given the diversity in timezones, I think probably a friday or weekday night (for PST and EST night-owls) and a sunday late-morning-to-afternoon (for London, EST early risers) session might work.  There is only so much DMing I can reasonably do, so 3-4 hour sessions are likely going to be more common than 6-8 hour ones; should still be plenty of time for an expedition, possibly two.  I would prefer to maintain some degree of cohesion across the player pool rather than division into two distinct parties, but if that happens then it happens.  I expect this will mostly depend on how players in the EST zone end up operating.  I will also do my best to not burn out like I did last time I ran two games a week, but I have better tools now for content generation and am more willing to constrain player action for the sake of sanity (see: the first half of this post) so I think this is significantly less likely than last time.

Obsidian Portal coming soon.  Honest.  At this point my list of things to do for prep is:
  • Build ObsPort
  • Begin mapping of Guano Cave dungeon
  • Start generating notable treasures for maps and rumors (scriptable)
  • Drop initial hook
  • Build some dynamic lairs
  • Demographic maths on the lizard realms
  • Market modifiers for coastal settlements (scriptable)
Possibility of first session is really only blocking on ObsPort and hook-drop, since I have that dungeon (sewers of Voltager) ready to run, but I'm going to be travelling all of next week and working unpredictable hours, so expect games to be starting the week after that.  At that time most of those bullets should be complete.  This weekend is juggling car repair, emptying my fridge, packing, and other travel preparations.

Thursday, November 7, 2013

Scaled Continent: A Brief History, and Current Situation

Long ago: Aura and environs ruled by the High Kings, divinely appointed.  Rule of Law expands; isles of Voltager settled.

2-3 centuries ago: Lizard kings invade Aura, overthrow High Kings with assistance of Voltari mercenaries and ships.  Torch and salt the forests of Argolle, dragon overlords crack open and plunder dwarven vaults.  Vast numbers of slaves shipped back across Sea of Tears to Scaled Continent for thirsty altars and hungry teeth.

~60 years ago: Dragon Emperor of the Lizardmen disappears mysteriously.  Empire begins to crumble under internal strife, civilized races rebel and gradually retake homelands, form Auran Republic of independent principalities.

5 years ago: Auran Legions dislodge snakemen from volcano-crater-mouth stronghold on Voltager by cutting their water supply and undermining their foundations.  Voltari mostly complicit.  Construction of permanent garrison on Voltager undertaken, along with aqueduct.  Taxes imposed, slave trade halted by Primipilus Galerian (commander of garrison of ~1500 soldiers) much to discontent of Voltari.  Piracy increases as a result, Auran-Voltari relations tense. 

Further expansion by the Legions onto the continent is hindered by inept seamanship, pirate activity, long distances, and institutional preference for galleys.  In preparation for future invasions, however, Galerian has been authorized to provide rewards both for maps of the continent and the capture of pirate vessels.  Meanwhile, grumbles in Voltager suggest that some members of the Council of Captains, a governing body comprised of captains both of ships and mercenaries, find the Primipilus onerous and would be pleased to see him ousted and replaced with someone more pliable.  The Temple of Ianna has been granted a religious exemption on pleasure slaves (an act of political necessity that Galerian no doubt regrets, but which his troops do not), and so supports the Auran garrison, while the Church of Yaris leaves each priest to his own judgment.  The Guild of Ship's Mages tends to support the Council out of alignment of interests.

Salvation, the largest settlement on the Isles of Voltager, is a class IV small city, but is treated as a class III market for the purposes of ruffians, mercenaries, mariners, ships, and trade goods as a result of its traditions and location.  Two other villages stand on the shores of Voltager - Timber, a logging village on the northeastern edge of Voltager Maxima, and Gemsands, a mining village on the eastern short of Voltager Minima.  The settlements on the coast of the Continent are mostly class V or VI, except for Stillwater and Port Maw, which are class IV large towns.  They were once larger, but the decline in slave traffic has caused much of their beastman populations to return to the jungle.